Gerard Butlerreprised his role as Stoick in the live-actionHow to Train Your Dragonmovie, but it’s not his first foray into the family-friendly fantasy genre. The Scottish-born star got his start in smaller roles before graduating to leading-man status in several major blockbusters in the 2000s. Putting his stamp on the action genre, Butler headlined movies like300andOlympus has Fallen, and consistently proves himself to be an action hero who can turn in a great performance too. However, Butler is also no stranger to other roles, and is deft at comedy as well.
Butler lent his voice to the gruff Viking, Stoick, intheHow to Train Your Dragonfilms, and he was perfectly cast as the stentorian figure who doesn’t understand his sensitive son, Hiccup. When it came to adapting the animated hit into a live-action film, Butler was one of the few original actors to return to his role. Once again, Butler was the perfect choice to play the live-action version of Stoick, and his dynamic with Hiccup had even more emotional weight in the live-action movie. 17 years before, Butler starred in another family fantasy film, and it’s worth revisiting.
Gerard Butler, Abigail Breslin, & Jodie Foster Star In Nim’s Island - What The Movie Is About
Butler Co-Stars In The Often Overlooked 2008 Blockbuster
Nearly 20 years beforeGerard Butler appeared in the live-actionHow to Train Your Dragonfilm, he got to flex his comedy muscles in 2008’sNim’s Island. The whimsical pseudo-fantasy film sees Butler co-star with Abigail Breslin and Jodie Foster, as a marine biologist who lives on a remote island with his precocious daughter. When Butler’s Jack Rusoe goes missing while on a research mission,Breslin’s Nim strikes up an unlikely friendship with an agoraphobic (Foster) author who writes some of her favorite adventure books.
What could have easily been a cut-and-paste family comedy with animals, actually strives for something more.
The movie is mostly made up of Nim’s fantasies, and she uses her ample imagination to dream up scenarios involving her fictional hero, Alex Rover. What could have easily been a cut-and-paste family comedy with animals, actually strives for something more. WhileNim’s Islandis far from perfect, it manages to surprise, and the main cast is excellent.Butler is correctly cast in his dual roles, and Abigail Breslin is just the right amount of spunky without going overboard.Jodie Foster also turns in a strong performance, and it’s rare for a children’s film to portray adults with realistic struggles.
Nim’s Island’s Subtle Fantasy Will Appeal To Fans Of How To Train Your Dragon
The Fantasy Comes Second Behind The Story Of Its Characters
ThoughNim’s Islandisn’t as good as theHow to Train Your Dragonfranchise, the underrated children’s film has similar elements that will catch the eye of fans of the blockbuster series. LikeHow to Train Your Dragon,Nim’s Islandis light on the fantasy elements and uses them mostly as spice for the story involving the characters. The dragons are really the most fantastical part of the franchise, and the movies never get bogged down in complex lore or over-the-top scenarios. Likewise,the fantasy inNim’s Islandis all imagination, so it doesn’t take away from what’s really happening.
Nim’s Islandgrossed $100 million, against a $37 million budget (viaBox Office Mojo).
Nevertheless, the island that Nim lives on is still a world of wonder, and isn’t unlike Berk. The setting for theDragonfilms is just a bit more exaggerated than in the real world, and Nim’s island is also more playful and whimsical than it would be in real life. Nim also has a deep connection with animals, like Hiccup’s with dragons, but it isn’t really a source of conflict inNim’s Island. Overall,few films are likeHow to Train Your Dragon, butNim’s Islandhas too many parallels to be ignored.
Two Different Parental Relationships In The Fantasy Movies
Image via Universal Pictures
Stoick is one of Gerard Butler’s best roles because he’s a complex look at what is essentially an action hero. He’s a legendary warrior, but his son, Hiccup, isn’t cut out for the Viking lifestyle.Butler plays an entirely different type of dad inNim’s Island, and it shows the actor’s range in less serious roles. Jack Rusoe is a brilliant marine biologist, and he trusts his daughter enough to leave her on the island by herself. Jack has a much stronger relationship with Nim than Stoick does with Hiccup, as evidenced by her fantasy vision of Alex Rover.
2008
53%
$100 million
2013
43%
$1 million
Butler plays both parts inNim’s Island, and it’s telling that when she imagines the fictional hero, he looks just like her dad. Meanwhile, Hiccup and Stoick are at odds throughout the first film in theHow to Train Your Dragonseries, and that’s because the trust isn’t there. They both represent two different approaches to a parental relationship, andGerard Butleris the secret ingredient that makes both films' characters shine.
