Jake Gyllenhaal is finally an Emmy nominee for the first time in his career after starring inPresumed Innocent. The2025 Emmy Award nominationsare being announced, with Jake Gyllenhaal in the running for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Limited or Anthology Series or Movie, 31 years after his first TV role.

WhilePresumed Innocenthas earned Gyllenhaal critical success, he won’t be returning for the show’s second season. The anthology format means the show will return with a fresh cast. Jake Gyllenhaal’s nomination will be a one-time deal, giving him one shot at a win against juggernauts like Colin Farrell and Stephen Graham.

Jake Gyllenhaal Rusty Sabich in Presumed Innocent

What Jake Gyllenhaal’s Emmy Situation Means

Jake Gyllenhaal Has A Low Chance Of Winning For Presumed Innocent

Movie stars like Al Pacino, Kevin Costner, and Mark Ruffalo have found success at the Emmys in this exact category, as actors known for their film careers will often pivot to television for a limited or anthology series. In Jake Gyllenhaal’s case,this might be one of his best opportunities in years to win a major award.

As mentioned,Gyllenhaal will be up against Colin Farrell (The Penguin) and Stephen Graham (Adolescence), both of whom have a promising chance of winning. Farrell already won the Golden Globe’s equivalent of this category earlier this year, while Graham’s show quickly became one of the most-viewed Netflix shows ever.

Presumed Innocent Key Art

If Jake Gyllenhaal continued withPresumed Innocent, he might have a better chance in the following years against less-prominent competition.

If Jake Gyllenhaal continued withPresumed Innocent, he might have a better chance in the following years against less-prominent competition. Anything can happen, but his chances to win the award aren’t stellar, and it will be a one-and-done for him.

Our Take On Jake Gyllenhaal’s Emmy Nomination

Jake Gyllenhaal Doesn’t Need To Prove Himself

Jake Gyllenhaal has played so many unforgettable characters in movies likeNightcrawlerandZodiac, yethe’s only ever been nominated for one Oscar and three Golden Globes. His performance inNightcrawleris often considered to be a massive snub for the Oscars, but it hasn’t detracted from its cultural impact or his.

Love him or hate him, Gyllenhaal is talented and continues to thrive in his career.Presumed Innocentwas a successful role for him, but he’s got plenty more on the way. 2024’sRoad Houseremake movie is one of the biggest hits of his career, so the momentum is evidently still there.