Although manySuitsfans are hoping an announcement forSuitsseason 10will eventually come, the fate of Meghan Markle’s character Rachel may make such a season rather challenging. Before Markle’s departure from the show, which coincided with her engagement to Prince Harry, Rachel was one of the most importantcharacters inSuits.

Despite Markle leaving the show two seasons beforetheSuitsfinale, she remained a key part of the story, in part because of her continued relationship withSuits’main character, Mike Ross.The fact that Markle has since retired from acting therefore poses a serious challenge forSuitsseason 10, especially because of the implications this has for the story.

Meghan Markle as Rachel Elizabeth Zane Smiling in Suits

Mike And Rachel Were Still Together And Living In Seattle At The End Of Suits

Breaking Rachel And Mike Up Would Be Unthinkable

Although Rachel wasn’t inSuitsseason 8 or 9, and Mike had only brief cameos in the show following the couple’s departure in season 7, it was clear thatMike and Rachel were still happily married at the end ofSuits. In fact, they were living in Seattle, and newlyweds Harvey and Donna were moving to work with them.

This ending cemented that Rachel and Mike’s marriage was going strong, but it also means that, ifSuitsseason 10 were to ever happen, it would presumably require Harvey, Donna, Mike, and Rachel all coming together, as that is precisely what the show’s finale set up.

Harvey and Mike wearing tuxes in Suits

IfSuitsseason 10 were to ever happen, it would presumably require Harvey, Donna, Mike, and Rachel all coming together.

Of course, there are ways the show could navigate this, but none of them seem particularly satisfying, and some of them would likely feel downright insulting. Perhapsthe most obvious choice the show could make is to have Rachel and Mike break up off-screen, but that would feel like such a disservice, for so many reasons.

03113358_poster_w780.jpg

For one, Mike and Rachel getting divorced would certainly be an event significant enough that it should be depicted on-screen, and only seeing the aftermath of it would be so disappointing. It’s possible that the show could give that story some depth from Mike’s perspective, but it would still feel like it was undercutting the importance of that relationship.

It would also feel out of left field, even if there was an explanation for how their relationship went wrong. Mike and Rachel had their issues, but there was no indication that the two were having any serious challenges, including when Mike returned in the final season of the show. From all that was shown, they remained deeply in love.

There are other options, such as having Rachel die off-screen, that would be even worse than the two being divorced. Even the most likely possibility of the show simply explaining away Rachel’s absence in various ways throughout the season would be dissatisfying and just wouldn’t work in the long-term.

Suits Season 10 Would Struggle To Justify Rachel’s Absence

Rachel Not Returning Could Only Be Explained For So Long

It feels more likely thatSuitsseason 10 would simply explain away Rachel’s absence in some way, rather than making a massive change like having Rachel and Mike divorce or killing Rachel off. After all, that is howSuitsmanaged to bring Mike Ross back after Markle had left the show.

While that worked with Mike’s minor cameos,it just isn’t realistic for the show to constantly find new reasons Rachel isn’t there. Particularly because the finale confirmed that Harvey and Donna would now be living near and working with Mike and Rachel, it would be much more difficult to constantly write Rachel out of scenes.

After more than a few excuses, this would begin to feel awkward and impossible to believe, which just wouldn’t be in the spirit of the show that has remained such a fan favorite even years after it concluded. In light of those complications, it’s possible thatSuitsseason 10 could never really come to be—but there are other possibilities.

A Suits Movie Would Be Easier To Pull Off Than Another Season

Having One Streamlined (Shorter) Story Could Work Better

WhileSuitsseason 10 might be too challenging to pull off for various reasons—Rachel’s absence among them—there is the possibility thataSuitsmovie might work so much better. While that may feel like a stretch, this show is no stranger to pivots, given there was originally a completelydifferent plan for Mike and Harvey inSuits.

Some fans may be disappointed ifSuitsreturned not as a full-fledged season 10 as many are hoping but rather as a movie, but there would be a number of benefits to this decision. For one, this would almost certainly resolve the concerns about Rachel’s character.

While Markle is still very unlikely to make an appearance even in a movie, as she does truly seem to have stepped away from acting,it would be much easier to have a succinct, focused story in a movie that doesn’t include Rachel than it would be to have many episodes that all need to explain Rachel’s absence.

Even beyond Rachel’s character, aSuitsmovie may very well be the best approach for the franchise to take, particularly in light ofthe cancelation ofSuits L.A.Suitsseason 10 may not suffer the same fate as the spin-off series because it would feature the beloved original cast, but a change in direction may not be a bad idea.

ASuitsmovie may very well be the best approach for the franchise to take.

At present, this is entirely speculative, as there are no official plans forSuitsto return at all. However, with the challenges Meghan Markle’s absence would pose, it may be best forSuitsto return not with season 10 but rather as a movie.